EU Court Withholds Ruling on Malta’s Bill 55, Leaving Key Legal Issues Open

Key Moments:

  • The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) declined to rule on Malta’s Bill 55.
  • Austrian litigation funder Spielerschutz Sigma challenged the law after Maltese courts rejected a foreign judgment.
  • Consequently, Malta’s legislation remains active, leaving its EU compliance unresolved.

Legal Background and Dispute

Controversy continues to surround Malta’s Bill 55. Specifically, the CJEU recently opted not to address the law’s compliance with European Union rules. The dispute began with Austrian litigation funder Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH. The firm backs Austrian players trying to recover gambling losses. These players targeted Malta-licensed operators that allegedly offered unauthorized services in Austria.

Malta enacted Bill 55 in 2023. Soon after, critics questioned the law’s validity under EU legislation. Legal advice on this issue later became central to a negligence claim. As a result, a court referred the matter to the CJEU in Luxembourg.

Scope and Impact of Malta’s Bill 55

Lawmakers introduced Bill 55 in June 2023 as Article 56A of Malta’s Gaming Act. First, it blocks legal actions against Malta-licensed gambling companies within Malta’s jurisdiction, provided the activities are legal locally. Furthermore, the provision requires Maltese courts to dismiss foreign judgments resulting from these claims.

In February, these protections proved effective. A Maltese civil court refused to enforce an Austrian ruling. That decision had ordered an MGA-licensed operator to reimburse nearly €500,000 to a player.

CJEU’s Position

Many critics argue that the legislation violates EU rules on recognizing judgments across member states. Therefore, Austria asked the CJEU to evaluate the issue. The request focused on the Brussels I Recast Regulation and Malta’s refusal to honor EU-wide rulings.

However, the CJEU decided it did not need to answer these questions. Instead, judges framed the case as a simple damages claim over legal advice given to Spielerschutz Sigma. Previously, a legal adviser had claimed that Bill 55 clearly conflicted with EU law. When a Maltese court rejected the Austrian judgment, Spielerschutz Sigma sued for negligence. The firm argued that this bad advice caused direct financial harm.

Ultimately, the CJEU ruled that determining negligence did not require judging Bill 55. The judges explained their reasoning in the official decision:

“In those circumstances, the Court notes that the lawfulness and proper performance of the reciprocal obligations of the parties to the legal consultation at issue are independent of the question of the compatibility of the relevant Maltese legislation with EU law,” the CJEU stated.

“Consequently, the Court finds that the interpretation of EU law which it would need to adopt in answer to the questions referred for a preliminary ruling would not meet an objective need for the resolution of the dispute in question and would not, therefore, be necessary for that resolution.”

Current Status

Because the CJEU refused to clarify the matter, Malta’s Bill 55 remains intact. Meanwhile, fundamental questions about its compatibility with EU law stay open for future legal challenges.

EventDateDetails
Bill 55 Introduced (Article 56A)June 2023Blocks actions against Malta-licensed operators for activities legal under Maltese law.
Maltese Court DecisionFebruaryRefused to enforce an Austrian ruling ordering a €500,000 player reimbursement.
CJEU RulingThursday (unspecified)Declined to address Bill 55’s EU compatibility during a negligence dispute.
  • Author

Daniel Williams

Daniel Williams has started his writing career as a freelance author at a local paper media. After working there for a couple of years and writing on various topics, he found his interest for the gambling industry.
Daniel Williams
Casino Guardian covers the latest news and events in the casino industry. Here you can also find extensive guides for roulette, slots, blackjack, video poker, and all live casino games as well as reviews of the most trusted UK online casinos and their mobile casino apps.

Related news